← All Tents

Coleman 8 Person Red Canyon Tent Coleman Montana 8 Person Tent

Head-to-head comparison: specs, scores and expert verdict

Coleman 8 Person Red Canyon Tent

Coleman

Coleman 8 Person Red Canyon Tent

★ 7.1 Dome
Sleeps 4 Seasons 3-season Weight 22.4 lbs Est. Price $135

Best for: Affordable, spacious family camping in warm weather.

Coleman Montana 8 Person Tent

Coleman

Coleman Montana 8 Person Tent

★ 7.0 Dome
Sleeps 4 Seasons 3-season Weight 23.14 lbs Est. Price $220

Best for: Budget-friendly family camping in mild weather.

Our Take

These are two versions of the same base tent from Coleman, so the differences come down to specific features rather than overall design.

Floor space is also wider — 170 sq ft versus 112 sq ft for the Coleman Montana 8 Person Tent.

Both score 7.1 overall, though the Coleman 8 Person Red Canyon Tent wins more individual scoring categories.

The biggest gap is intangibles, where the Coleman 8 Person Red Canyon Tent holds a clear advantage.

The Coleman 8 Person Red Canyon Tent also has a price edge — $84 less at $134 versus $219.

Check the full specs below to see exactly what sets these two apart and decide whether the difference is worth it to you.

🏆 Our pick: The Coleman 8 Person Red Canyon Tent scores higher overall.

Still deciding between these two?

Ask our AI for a personalised recommendation based on your camping style, group size, and budget.

Score Comparison

Coleman 8 Person Red Canyon Tent
Coleman Montana 8 Person Tent
Overall Score
7.1
7.0
Space & Comfort
8.0
7.5
Quality & Durability
6.0
6.5
Weather Resistance
7.0
7.0
Value for Money
7.0
7.0
Ease of Use
7.0
7.0
Intangibles
6.0
5.0

Pros & Cons

Coleman 8 Person Red Canyon Tent

  • Fits 3 queen airbeds
  • 15-minute simple setup
  • Massive 140-square-foot floor
  • Thin rainfly poles
  • Single door access

Coleman Montana 8 Person Tent

  • Hinged door access
  • Angled rainproof windows
  • Quick 15-minute setup
  • Fragile fiberglass poles
  • Zero side windows

Full Specs

SpecColeman 8 Person Red Canyon TentColeman Montana 8 Person Tent
Tent Type Dome, 3 Room Dome
Capacity 4 people 4 people
Seasons 3 Season 3 Season
Est. Price $135 $220
Weight 22.4 Lbs 23.14 Lbs
Floor Area 170.0 ft² 112.0 ft²
Peak Height 72 74
Doors 1 1
Floor Dimensions 17 X 10 Ft 16 X 7 Ft
Pole Material Fiberglass Fiberglass
Floor Fabric Polyguard™ Polyester Fabric Polyguard™ Polyester Fabric
Rainfly Fabric Polyguard™ Polyester Fabric Polyguard™ Polyester Fabric
Setup Time 15 Mins 20 Mins
Warranty 1 Year Limited 1 Year Limited
Made In Imported Imported

Ready to Buy?

Coleman

Coleman 8 Person Red Canyon Tent

Coleman

Coleman Montana 8 Person Tent

Still not sure? Let us recommend the perfect tent for your adventures.

Find Your Perfect Tent →