← All Tents

Montana Canvas Relite Spike III Tent White Duck 10' Regatta Canvas Bell 4 Person Tent with Stove Jack

Head-to-head comparison: specs, scores and expert verdict

Montana Canvas Relite Spike III Tent

Montanta Canvas

Montana Canvas Relite Spike III Tent

★ 8.3 Wall
Sleeps 3 Seasons 4-season Weight 86 lbs Est. Price $2,150

Best for: Base camp for couples or small families.

White Duck 10' Regatta Canvas Bell 4 Person Tent with Stove Jack

White Duck

White Duck 10' Regatta Canvas Bell 4 Person Tent with Stove Jack

★ 8.5 Bell
Sleeps 4 Seasons 4-season Weight 51 lbs Est. Price $590

Best for: Four-season canvas camping with wood stove.

Our Take

Worth flagging before you compare: the Montana Canvas Relite Spike III Tent is a wall and the White Duck 10' Regatta Canvas Bell 4 Person Tent with Stove Jack is a bell, so these two sit in different shelter categories.

The White Duck 10' Regatta Canvas Bell 4 Person Tent with Stove Jack sleeps 4 versus 3 for the Montana Canvas Relite Spike III Tent — if headcount matters, that's the deciding factor before you even look at scores.

Floor space is also wider — 144 sq ft versus 79 sq ft for the White Duck 10' Regatta Canvas Bell 4 Person Tent with Stove Jack.

The Montana Canvas Relite Spike III Tent and the White Duck 10' Regatta Canvas Bell 4 Person Tent with Stove Jack are remarkably well-matched, both scoring 8.3 overall.

The biggest gap is space and comfort, where the Montana Canvas Relite Spike III Tent holds a clear advantage.

The White Duck 10' Regatta Canvas Bell 4 Person Tent with Stove Jack also has a price edge — $1559 less at $590 versus $2149.

Your best pick will come down to personal priorities, so check the full specs comparison below.

Score Comparison

Montana Canvas Relite Spike III Tent
White Duck 10' Regatta Canvas Bell 4 Person Tent with Stove Jack
Overall Score
8.3
8.5
Space & Comfort
10.0
8.0
Quality & Durability
9.0
8.0
Weather Resistance
10.0
9.0
Value for Money
5.0
7.0
Ease of Use
7.0
9.0
Intangibles
9.0
9.0

Pros & Cons

Montana Canvas Relite Spike III Tent

  • Integrated stove jack
  • Lightweight Relite material
  • Internal aluminum frame
  • Heavy 86-pound package
  • Misleading fabric name

White Duck 10' Regatta Canvas Bell 4 Person Tent with Stove Jack

  • Pre-installed heat-resistant stove jack
  • Breathable DYNATEK performance canvas
  • 15-minute solo setup pitch
  • Heavy 51-pound weight
  • Obstructive doorway pole

Full Specs

SpecMontana Canvas Relite Spike III TentWhite Duck 10' Regatta Canvas Bell 4 Person Tent with Stove Jack
Tent Type Wall, Hot Tent Bell, Hot Tent, Glamping
Capacity 3 people 4 people
Seasons 4 Season 4 Season
Est. Price $2,150 $590
Weight 86 Lbs 51 Lbs
Floor Area 144.0 ft² 78.5 ft²
Peak Height 84 89
Doors 2 1
Floor Dimensions 12x12 With 4' Sidewalls
Pole Material Aluminum Alloy Reinforced With 1" Steel Conduit Galvanized Steel
Floor Fabric Relite Polyester Floor 7.5 Oz. Biodegradable Sewn In PE Groundsheet
Rainfly Fabric Weatherproof DYNATEK Canvas
Setup Time 10 Mins 15 Mins
Warranty Limited Lifetime Warranty Lifetime
Made In USA Imported

Ready to Buy?

Montanta Canvas

Montana Canvas Relite Spike III Tent

White Duck

White Duck 10' Regatta Canvas Bell 4 Person Tent with Stove Jack

Still not sure? Let us recommend the perfect tent for your adventures.

Find Your Perfect Tent →